Posted on

One Hymn, Two Voices: The Night of the Hunter

Film · United States · 1955

In Charles Laughton’s only feature as a director, a familiar hymn moves between a predatory preacher and the woman guarding two children. Its melody becomes a small, uneasy map of the film’s larger world: faith can be performed as a threat, or practiced as shelter.

Director: Charles Laughton · Cast: Robert Mitchum, Shelley Winters, Lillian Gish; Billy Chapin and Sally Jane Bruce as the children · Screenplay: James Agee, from Davis Grubb’s 1953 novel · Photography: Stanley Cortez · Music: Walter Schumann

Film: United States, 1955 · black-and-white · English · 93 min. (Criterion listing)

World premiere: Des Moines, Iowa, 26 July 1955. Los Angeles opened 26 August; New York opened 29 September. AFI Catalog. Selected for the U.S. National Film Registry in 1992 (Library of Congress).

Rotten Tomatoes, checked 3 Nov 2026: 93% Tomatometer (86 critic reviews); 90% Popcornmeter (25,000+ audience ratings). Separate measures, not an average. Source.

Original 1955 theatrical poster: Robert Mitchum towers over Shelley Winters beneath the title The Night of the Hunter
1955 United Artists theatrical poster, scan via Heritage Auctions. © United Artists; presented here as a small editorial reference to the film’s original campaign imagery.

The Night of the Hunter begins with a secret too large for a child to carry alone. In Depression-era West Virginia, John and Pearl Harper know where their father hid money taken in a robbery. A traveling preacher, Harry Powell, learns of the secret and draws close to their widowed mother. The children’s fear becomes the film’s compass: adults may mistake a confident voice for goodness, while the young hear the danger in it.

Laughton was already a celebrated English-born actor, with decades of stage and screen work behind him; this was the only feature he directed. The combination could have been a standard crime chase. Instead, the film moves between domestic detail, religious fable and a night world shaped like a child’s nightmare. In 1992, the Library of Congress selected it for the National Film Registry. It remains an unusually personal piece of Hollywood filmmaking, neither a naturalistic period drama nor a conventional horror picture.

The hymn changes hands

“Leaning on the Everlasting Arms” is credited as a traditional hymn in the AFI Catalog, separate from the film’s original songs. Walter Schumann wrote the score and, with novelist Davis Grubb, several original songs. The distinction matters: the tune arrives with a public history and a promise of comfort already attached to it. Powell borrows that promise. He sings while moving through the dark, and his soft, recognizable melody can reach the children before his body does.

Then Rachel Cooper, played by Lillian Gish, takes up the same hymn from inside her house as Powell waits outside. She has a rifle in her lap; the music is not a surrender. The notes join them across a boundary the camera keeps visible: he is exposed in the yard, she is framed behind the house’s threshold. Their voices share a tune but not an authority. Powell uses religion as a costume for appetite; Rachel’s faith is measured by the children she takes in and the danger she refuses to romanticize. The melody changes hands without becoming safe. It carries the threat of his approach and the steadiness of her answer at once.

That doubleness is why the song does more than announce the villain. It makes the film’s moral conflict audible before it is resolved. Powell’s voice is at once musical and invasive: a hymn that should console becomes a warning system. Schumann’s score lets folk and hymn material sit beside orchestral unease, so the sound world is never simply “good music” against “bad music.” The children live in the space between those signals, listening for which adult voice can be trusted. The tune’s return also prevents the film’s religious language from being reduced to a simple argument against belief; the danger lies in a man who claims the sacred as his private license.

Critics have disagreed over how bluntly the film draws that line. In his 1955 New Yorker review, John McCarten found Laughton too caught in allegory, especially in the contrast between the preacher and Rachel, even as he praised Mitchum and the cast. Decades later, BFI critic Geoff Andrew admired the film’s expressionist-pastoral images but noted that a few broadly comic turns in Powell can jar. Terrence Rafferty, writing for Criterion, sees that comic collapse as part of the point: evil is frightening, but Laughton and Mitchum also strip it of grandeur. The hymn holds these readings together. Its grace is real; the man singing it is not thereby redeemed.

A river made on a soundstage

The film’s second great movement is visual rather than musical: the children leave the cramped rooms and roads of the adults for a river that seems to have no shore. Laughton and cinematographer Stanley Cortez do not maintain one stable kind of realism. A bedroom can become a black stage with a sharply outlined doorway; a preacher’s shadow enlarges on a wall; the night sky can flatten him into a storybook cutout. The images feel designed, not observed from a neutral distance, and that design moves the story toward the children’s scale.

According to Criterion’s essay, Laughton screened silent films by D. W. Griffith while preparing the picture, and the choice of Gish—one of Griffith’s defining stars—as the children’s protector makes that history visible without turning the film into a museum piece. Cortez, who had photographed Orson Welles’s The Magnificent Ambersons, gives the black-and-white frame both hard edges and open air. Griffith-like frontal compositions and iris effects can sit beside unnerving shadows and comic exaggeration. The result lets the audience feel that a familiar house, a tree or a river might change its meaning when seen from below, where adults loom and the night is immense.

The river voyage looks like a passage through an enchanted landscape: a small boat drifts beneath oversized frogs, rabbits, birds and spiderwebs, each animal held close in the foreground while the children remain farther away. Yet the apparent wilderness was carefully made. In an interview later published by the American Cinematographer, Cortez recalled that the river sequence was filmed on Stage 15 at RKO-Pathé Studios. Chuck Bowen’s analysis of the composited animals helps explain why the boat and river read as a constructed image; their impossible scale makes the world less like a postcard view than a child’s alert dream. The river is not a documentary landscape. It is a refuge imagined from scraps of natural life, a space large enough to carry the children beyond the reach of the town.

Open a later film still (contains a story reveal)
Black-and-white image of a submerged car in the river from The Night of the Hunter, presented by Criterion Collection
Later river image, presented in Criterion’s essay. Copyright in the film image remains with its rights holder.

The shift also changes how the film treats adults. Before the river, the town’s routines—courtship, churchgoing, gossip, family roles—allow Powell to pass as respectable. On the water, the children have no such social script. They have a boat, a secret, and the ability to recognize danger. Rachel’s home later offers a different kind of domestic order: she houses abandoned children and gives them work, food and rules without disguising care as possession. The contrast is not simply between a wicked man and a good woman; it is between systems that claim children and a home that makes room for them.

That does not make the film’s moral design entirely comfortable. Its adults can be types, and its good-and-evil pattern is deliberately emphatic. McCarten’s complaint about overworked allegory still names a real pressure in the film. But the fairy-tale clarity has a purpose: children should not have to interpret predation as a subtle misunderstanding. Laughton lets a shadow become a shadow, a song become a signal, a river become an escape route. The symbols are large because the threat is, too.

The Night of the Hunter is often remembered for the tattooed words on Powell’s fingers, but its most durable image may be the one made by sound: a hymn held between the man who weaponizes it and the woman who answers him. One song cannot guarantee safety or innocence. It can, however, tell the children—and us—that the same words may serve very different lives.

Look for: the shift from the lit bedroom to the wide, staged river, and how the hymn travels between Powell outside and Rachel within.

Watch: The Night of the Hunter (1955) trailer, an official Criterion Collection upload on YouTube. Video playback was not tested in this package check.